Session D3 - Pollution in SCMs: characterisation

Theme: Source control measures - Monitoring & modelling

Tuesday, June 30

 16:35 - VENDITTI Silvia, FAGHIH NASIRI Elaheh, NUNEZ TAFALLA Paula, PETERS Helene, HANSEN Joachim, GRITTEN Fanny, DITTMER Ulrich / Luxembourg

Intensified nature-based solutions for micropollutant removal from combined sewer overflows: from laboratory experiments to pilot design

Combined sewer overflows (CSOs) occur when the discharge in combined sewer systems exceeds the hydraulic capacity of the WWTP and storage volume in the system is reached. This results in the discharge of untreated wastewater/stormwater mixtures into receiving water bodies. In addition to conventional contaminants, CSOs convey a broad spectrum of micropollutants, from domestic and non-domestic sewage (e.g. pharmaceuticals, personal care product residues) and from surface runoff (e.g. pesticides, and microplastics). In this study, Nature-based solutions (NBS) were developed for the treatment of CSO discharges within the Sûre catchment, a cross-border area between Luxembourg, Germany and Belgium (Wallonie). Locally available materials were selected and subsequently characterized for their suitability as substrates in retention soil filters. Under controlled mesocosm conditions (i.e. synthetic water, spiked active ingredients, constant temperature), these systems achieved removal efficiencies exceeding 92% for 18 targeted micropollutants, in average. Furthermore, locally produced biochars were evaluated as potential admixture components to conventional sand substrates to enhance micropollutant removal from CSO discharges. The outcomes of this first phase have been used to design pilot plants that are installed in the Sûre catchment, both in Luxembourgish and Belgian sides. The presentation will also contain first results obtained from these pilots. 

Long abstract

 16:55 - PHILLIPS Ben, WITTER Jon, WINSTON Ryan / Ohio State University - USA

Evaluating water quality improvements in grassed, wetland, and unvegetated swales treating highway runoff

Stormwater quantity and quality within 3 co-located swales with different vegetative conditions (grassed, vegetated wetland, and unvegetated wetland) were monitored along a stretch of US highway 23 near Upper Sandusky, Ohio. Wetland conditions occurring within roadside swales are often unintended; therefore, periodic maintenance may be done to remove hydrophytic vegetation and accumulated sediment from the swale, resulting in unvegetated (i.e., “dipped out”) wetland conditions. Between July 2023 to July 2024, ISCO 6712 automated samplers collected flow-paced runoff samples and runoff hydrographs used to calculate annual pollutant loading rates (kg/ha/yr) and watershed runoff depths (watershed-mm) for each treatment. A total of 760 mm of rainfall occurred during the monitoring period. The unvegetated wetland condition conveyed the greatest annual sediment (583 kg/ha/yr), total phosphorus (TP; 0.96 kg/ha/yr), total nitrogen (4.52 kg/ha/yr), and runoff depth (283 watershed-mm) of all vegetation treatments. This is likely driven by the exposure of runoff to bare soils and reduced channel roughness following wetland swale dredging. In contrast, the vegetated wetland condition conveyed a lower runoff depth (13.25 watershed-mm) than the unvegetated wetland swale along with the lowest sediment, TP, and dissolved phosphorus loading rates amongst all treatments. Unintended wetland conditions within roadside swales serve to reduce runoff volume as well as hyperaccumulate sediment and nutrients from runoff. Wetland roadside swales provide a cost-effective means to reduce pollutant loads.

Long abstract

 17:15 - POTREAU Sarah, BLANC Denise, WIEST Laure, GIROUD Barbara, TEDOLDI Damien, CHATAIN Vincent, BACOT Laetitia, GAUTIER Mathieu / INSA Lyon DEEP - France

Intensified nature-based solutions for micropollutant removal from combined sewer overflows: from laboratory experiments to pilot design

Urban desealing raises questions about the fate of contaminants in stormwater runoff. Particulate and dissolved phases are relatively well documented, but colloidal phases remain poorly studied in urban environments. The ROCOCO project (role of colloids and particles in the dynamics of contaminants in urban stormwater runoff) aims to characterize the distribution of contaminants within different fractions. A centrifugal ultrafiltration methodology allowed the separation of four fractions (>0.45 µm, 0.45 µm-30 kDa, 30-3 kDa, <3 kDa) from samples collected at two Observatoire de Terrain en Hydrologie Urbaine (OTHU) sites. Results showed that contaminants are predominantly associated with the particulate phase, and revealed variable distribution of metals (Al, Cr, Cu, Fe, Zn and Ti) between dissolved and colloidal phases of the <0.45 µm fraction. Pesticides and pharmaceuticals were mainly found in the dissolved phase. These data can provide information for the design of infiltration systems and contribute to the assessment of contaminant migration risks to groundwater.

Long abstract

 17:35 - FASSMAN-BECK Elizabeth, XIN Danhui / Southern California Coastal Water Research Project - USA

Microplastics removal and accumulation in Southern California biofilters

Stormwater runoff is emerging as a significant contributor of microplastics (MP) to downstream waterways. To begin to answer management questions on this emerging contaminant, we sought to quantify the extent to which existing biofilter (a.k.a. bioretention) stormwater control measures reduce MP, and to evaluate whether engineered media specifications are adequate to capture the range of MP sizes occurring in runoff. We conducted a field monitoring study to measure MP event mean concentrations (EMCs) and size distributions (20 µm to >500 µm) in influent and effluent and quantify accumulation in engineered media with respect to the media’s pore and particle size distributions. Across 18 storm events collected from7 biofilters, median MP EMC reduction was 72%, EMC reduction ranged from 68–100% for different size fractions. Physical filtration (i.e., straining) was identified as the dominant removal mechanism for MPs in biofilters, supported by the close correspondence between the removal of MPs and all particles remaining after extraction. Media with a larger proportion of pores < 20 m accumulated more MP. The strong alignment in occurrence and removal across a wide concentration range indicates that all particle counts may serve as a practical surrogate for estimating MP occurrence and BMP treatment in urban runoff.

Long abstract

Sarah Potreau Denise Blanc Laure Wiest Barbara Giroud Damien Tedoldi Vincent Chatain Laetitia Bacot Mathieu Gautier Elizabeth Fassman-Beck Danhui Xin Ben Phillips Jon Witter Ryan Winston  Silvia Venditti Elaheh Faghih Nasiri Paula Nunez Tafalla Helene Peters Joachim Hansen Fanny Gritten Ulrich Dittmer